In the past week the Battle of Viewpoints has been fought within the pages of my novel.
Automatically I started writing in the the third person, feeling comfortable and at ease.
Then one of the main characters clamoured to be heard and as an experiment I switched to her first person voice.
The result was not the triumphant powerful success which I had imagined.
Although I enjoyed being in my character’s head and travelling with her thoughts and observations on paper (or screen), my writing suddenly became simplified. This could be as the character at this stage is a young girl aged 10 and my language in her voice couldn’t help but reflect her youth.
Furthermore the passages of description which I feel are critical to the story became lost as the need to describe the settings became superfluous since they are familiar to the character. Any such description became false and forced.
Often writers use first person as this allows the reader to quickly engage and identify with the character, thereby drawing them into the story. I have often written from this viewpoint in my short stories and found it ideal. There is one danger though and that is the reader is limited to that one character’s perception of the story, through their eyes only. It is virtually impossible to introduce any events away from the character. One way to add further dimensions in the first person perspective is to use two or more characters.
Having just read ‘The Invention of Wings’ by Sue Monk Kidd I did consider this approach. In her wonderful book there are two narrators: the slave girl, Handful and the slave owner’s daughter, Sarah Grimké, who alternatively swap the story telling and thereby relate two very diverse and diametrically opposing worlds and experiences.
As I could not imagine two characters alone carrying the my story I knew more would be needed and was concerned this could be become cumbersome.
At one stage whilst discussing my dilemma with a friend she questioned if I could use both first and third person? I hesitated and gave the notion a thought. I cannot remember reading any books written thus, but perhaps they do exist. The mental and emotional logistics of such a narration though seemed fraught with difficulties and pitfalls, so I decided to avoid that route and instead reverted to the third person.
On the whole it was a relief to return to the third person viewpoint. The floaty descriptions returned but now enhanced with a third person perspective. The distant narrator is replaced with a more personal viewpoints of the characters.
Although the chapters are not headed by the which character is leading the story, there do exist ‘signposts’ very early on showing which character’s viewpoint will dominate the chapter. I now retain the freedom to write about events well outside the characters if required whilst ensuring characters are personable and well-rounded. To avoid confusion I am sticking to four character viewpoints in the third person, this gives me the breadth to explore their emotional and inner feelings and thoughts of each one. The plot will still be pacey whilst other characters and subplots can be easily introduced.
In her book, ‘Sunrise’, Victoria Hislop writes beautifully and in the third person, so effectively at times I didn’t realise it wasn’t in the first person. The pain, anguish, deceit and love of the characters are depicted with startling vitality.
The battle is over, calm reigns and now I just have to rewrite a couple of chapters. No problem.
I told myself reading was a kind of freedom, the only one I could give.
Sarah Grimké in ‘The Invention of Wings’ by Sue Monk Kidd
Current word count of first draft of my novel: 14,940 words
4 thoughts on “Battle of Views”
Thanks but not so heavy when working through it a stage at a time. Retrospectively is another matter…
I love this blog. How you show the difficulty of writing in
first person; amazed at how involved you were to make the
first person change your language.
Glad you now can forge ahead with the help of a third person’s eyes.
Love the slow opening of the tulip
Thank you, it was interesting and fun trying the different viewpoints but glad to finally sort what I wanted – cleared my mind. Look forward to Spring and more tulips awakening to greet the warmth.
Wow; HEAVY stuff!